Rated 1 out of 5 by Arthurs Mom from It's not a tray Having bought boot trays from Garnet Hill before, I expected a boot tray, with a 2-inch (or so) rim around its perimeter. However, this is simply an expensive thick mat for shoes and boots. It is definitely not a tray. I bought it for my college student, who isn't that picky. But if I had bought it for myself, I would have definitely returned it.