Rated 4 out of 5 by DiscoDancerBoston from Love the color...not the shape I purchased this dress in a small (5'6", 140 lbs, athletic/straight build, usually wear a 6 or 8). I absolutely LOVE the cider color. It is a rich, cognac brown--very flattering on pale-ish brunettes. The cashmere is, as some mentioned, a bit on the thinner side, but not terribly thin. It's very soft, as is generally the case with Garnet Hill cashmere. However, the shape does absolutely nothing for me. In fact, it looks a bit like a potato sack on--despite being the correct size. I should have paid more attention to the description. It does say that the dress is slightly cocoon shaped. That is definitely true. I could've used a bit of waist shaping or something to make it look more like how it looks on the models. As it stands, I look more like Dorothy from the Golden Girls (minus the shoulder pads, of course). So it's going back...but I sure hope GH will make more in this color!

Rated 4 out of 5 by RobNana from Nice but a bit thin! I bought this and decided to keep it because I liked the color so much. The cashmere is thinner than others that I have purchased. It's still warm. Would like it to be a bit less clingy but over all I like the dress.

Rated 3 out of 5 by PandP from Lovely but thin Very nice dress. It has a great shape and is the perfect length. I'm 5'2" and it comes just above my knee. I usually take xs in dresses, but bought a small this time. it was the perfect choice - it fits well without clinging. Only complaint: it is super thin. The material is more like a light sweater than a sweater dress. It looks more substantial in the photo than in real life. I'm sad about that.