Rated 4 out of 5 by loving cashmeres from too boxy for me? The quality of Garnet Hill cashmeres are always way above average in my book, but I'm not loving this sweater. I ordered it in the black fleck and in my usual M for my 5'4" 130 lbs body. The pluses: soft medium-weight fabric, nice shawl collar (not overwhelming if your neck is short), long sleeves with good cuffs you can fold back. The minuses: the white flecks are so tiny you almost don't see them, the black hides the pretty seam detailing, and the shape almost balloons out at the bottom. A smaller size might be better, and a different color would show the detailing, but none of the other colors suit me (I need that heathery/mossy/forest green from past years!). If you give this a try, I recommend sizing down.