Rated 5 out of 5 by Sandy8 from Great features! Perfect fit and beautiful cashmere quality. Have received numerous compliments.

Rated 4 out of 5 by Travelling Frances from Love the versatility I have so many Garnet Hill cashmere sweaters and did not need another, BUT....this one reminded me of a sweater I loved about 15 years ago, so I caved. I am currently wearing it, which makes 3 wears in a week. It is soft (but not delicate, which is nice, so I feel like I don't have to be so careful while wearing it), the dark brown has interesting texture and flecks of color and will work both for weekends and work, over nice slacks or a skirt or dress. My only quibble is that the t-neck could have been longer so when unbuttoned hung into more of a cowl neck. Mine doesn't hang like the pictures (and I even counted the buttons to make sure I was doing it correctly), so I will probably wear it more often as a standard turtleneck sweater - but I do really like it and it is a keeper.

Rated 4 out of 5 by ann521 from a little rough but beautiful silhouette The silhouette of this button turtleneck is what grabbed me. I actually hate turtlenecks, but I loved the idea of being able to unbutton it and have the asymmetrical draped collar, which is how I'm sure I'll always wear it. I'm 5'5", 120 lbs, large chested, and usually wear a small, but I ordered this in x-small because I didn't want it to be too boxy. The fit is perfect. Not form-fitting by any means, but I'm not swimming in it, which is exactly what I wanted. If that's also the look you're going for, I might suggest sizing down. Also the sweater wasn't as bulky as I was expecting, which was great because I'd actually worried when I ordered it that it would be too thick. The only reason I gave it 4 stars is that the cashmere is a little rough and scratchy--nothing to give a rash, but not as soft as cashmere pieces I've had in the past. I've never owned recycled cashmere before, so maybe that's why? I always wear at least a camisole under cashmere, so I'm not too worried and it's not enough for me to send it back. I was just a little disappointed that it wasn't as soft as I'd expected.