Rated 5 out of 5 by potomac from new brand for me I was hesitant based on the reviews of others but am very happy with my purchase. They are taking a bit of time to break in but I have not had the same issue with the heel. I really love the way these shoes look as they are less clunky than many loafers.

Rated 5 out of 5 by melody jean from Love the shoe Class act shoe. However, runs very small add a pair sock and I will have 2 go up 2 sizes.

Rated 1 out of 5 by Rhea from Design malfunction Based on the reviews I ordered up a half size from 8 1/2 to 9, but for me the 9 was HUGE. Exchanged for and 8 1/2. Also huge, but main problem with it is that the back part drops off my foot when walking. Operates like a flip-flop. I tried heavy socks with them to see if sizing down further would help, but no. Still the stiff sole was flopping off my foot when walking. A shame really as the leather is beautiful. FYI I bought the tan. Maybe the black is different? I’m done wasting money on shipping.

Rated 1 out of 5 by Mjpack from Defective design Order the shoe once it was extremely too small. Ordered one an entire size up 7.5. Foot has a hard time getting in. Goes back and forth. Clearly is a defective shoe or my foot is. Never have had a problem buying shoes before. I would not waste your time or money. I am going to demand shipping cost back as this shoe is defective! Garnett hill you can do better than this!!!!