Rated 5 out of 5 by Leene from Best ever! I wore this sweater for the first time today. The most comfortable and warm sweater that I have ever owned. I will definitely wear this sweater out. Love, love, love it! Thanks Garnet Hill you did good.

Rated 5 out of 5 by kwick from Cozy + flattering This was a Christmas gift to myself, and I love it. The cotton-alpaca blend is thick and warm. The v-neck gives it a touch of sexiness. It's got a loose fit that looks great with jeans. And I love the pattern; it's not like any other sweater in my closet. I got the blue-and-rust version, the colors are beautiful and well-represented on the website. For reference I'm 5'4" and about 120 lbs.

Rated 5 out of 5 by rzavvy from Beautiful and So Unique Most of my sweaters from GH are cashmere and natural colors, so I took a chance on this pattern and I really l love it! I am 5'6" and 142 lbs, broad shoulders and 36A-B bra size. I ordered both small and medium and I'm keeping the small, but both would have worked for me. I have longer arms and there isn't much difference in the arm length - both go to my wrist. The difference seems to be only in the width. I also have a longer torso, but it doesn't seem to be that cropped to me. It's only a bit shorter than my other sweaters. It's a heavier cotton and the alpaca gives it a bit of extra warmth. I don't find it itchy. I plan on hand washing and I really hope it doesn't shrink. I'm happy I tried this one!

Rated 5 out of 5 by Ninette from Love this sweater Other reviews say that this is short...and it is. It's a cropped sweater, really, and you can see it on the model. So I was expecting that. Love everything about it...feels great, and the blue pattern is gorgeous.

Rated 4 out of 5 by BostonShoeLover from A gorgeous sweater I took away a star because the sizing is so wonky! The XS is very oversized, but I LOVE the navy/brick colors, floral design, and the soft cushy cotton/alpaca fabric! I seriously thought about returning it, but decided to try removing the cuffs from the enormously long sleeves, slim down the sleeves a bit, shorten the length, and reattach the cuffs. The style will still be batwing & very roomy on me, but I think this will make it wearable; I'll attempt the work this fall. I knit constantly, so do I really need another sweater?? Absolutely not, but this one is different & beautiful enough to keep.

Rated 3 out of 5 by Vsilk from Jacquard Sweater The sweater, in dark shades, is very pretty. However, it is not as soft and gorgeously made as the last GH sweater I bought last year, which is cashmere.

Rated 3 out of 5 by Chidori from Should be called a "cropped sweater" It's pretty and well made but definitely short, even the XL size. Arm lengths are good but would have liked a couple more inches in length. I do really like the fabric combination of cotton and alpaca. Soft, no itch.

Rated 2 out of 5 by ValNY from Dye bled when washed I love this sweater! It is gorgeous and comfy and ver unique. That is why I was so upset when the color dye bled upon first washing. I followed the washing instructions and did hand washing in cold water.

Rated 2 out of 5 by Mpls gal from Too boxy I was excited to receive this sweater. The color is beautiful but I was disappointed with the fit too large, boxy and too short. I had to return it. I ordered a small and thought the xsmall arm length would be too short.

Rated 1 out of 5 by Enne from Itchy & Unwearable Chose this cotton and "baby" alpaca sweater because I expected it to be soft. Something about the construction of the neckline sends me up the wall. It's in the freezer, the 4th step in a process alleged to reduce the itch. What a waste of money.