Rated 3 out of 5 by KD in NC from Not for petites Not meant for petites. The dress was overwhelming on a small frame and came down to my ankles (5’2”). The sewing on the belt tie wasn’t great. Overall not good. Returned it.

Rated 2 out of 5 by Jo Jane from Odd I sent this back. I thought it would be a smooth, cozy flannel, but it was just a blah sort of thin woven cotton. It was ill-fitting on me. It buttons partially in front and partially inside the bodice and the waist was exceedingly high (I am high waisted,) leading to an odd drape. Loved the color though.

Rated 2 out of 5 by janders082 from Not As Pictured I really think they did some sneaky styling/tailoring on this dress to make it look like it does on the model. It is is essentially a giant flannel tube with side ties. It's also super long. Usually, with my long torso, midi dresses hit exactly where they should, even though I am 5'3" but this one...it hits in this no-man's-land between the bottom of my calf and my ankle and it is so unflattering. The fabric is flannel, but the grey isn't brushed, so it looks like a work shirt. This isn't the cozy flannel of the Garnet Hill pajamas, this is something much more utilitarian and, dare I say, rough. The weave of the fabric has no structure, so it looks slouchy, even once I fixed the collar to look like the picture. Since returns aren't truly free in my area, I am not returning this dress. I will have to have it tailored, shortened, and probably do something with the ties before I can wear this in public and not feel like I'm halfway to being a Victorian factory worker.

Rated 2 out of 5 by JA in OH from Really wanted to love it It looks amazing in the picture but oh my it looks awful in real life. It is overwhelming and I am a tall woman. It does not drape nicely, the fabric is heavy, and not flattering at all. Had to return.

Rated 1 out of 5 by Dorothy123 from Army robe Sadly, the fabric feels and looks like a prison robe. Does not look as elegant as on the picture. Looks stiff, cheap, and... scary even.

Rated 1 out of 5 by Seattle mom from Had to return Not flattering for the curvy short woman- I'm 5'4" and a size 12- I had to return this dress, it made me look wide and squat. I think it would be better for someone taller, but not great for someone short with curves.