Rated 5 out of 5 by Traci R from Surprised by Negative Reviews I was so surprised by the negative reviews. My closet is filled with Eileen Fisher and I love her silhouettes. I bought my typical size (small) and it fits perfectly in the shoulders and was a-line as I expected. The fabric was lovely and this will be a go-to dress for me this summer—perfect for work or the weekends.

Rated 3 out of 5 by AnnieUrban from Voluminous I’m 5’2 and 125 lbs. Slender. Three of me could have fit comfortably in this dress. It’s beautifully made. There’s just way too much volume. I returned it. Size S.

Rated 3 out of 5 by LiveFree from Shapeless, drab & 100% SEE-THROUGH ☹️ I bought a size L, which fits me fine. This is a comfortable yet completely shapeless, baggy dress. I could get away with wearing it during extreme heat waves IF the fabric wasn’t Doo SEE THROUGH! This dress comes with NO LINER NOR SLIP, so I would have to buy a full slip & have it altered specifically for this dress’s length and sleevelessness. Plus, most likely have the slip straps sewn into the dress, so they never fall off my shoulders and are seen. NOPE! -for the steep price of this two hundred plus dollar dress, I should NOT have to do any of this! This is an immodest, unwearable dress, as it was sent to me. The color is exceedingly drab and “UNFUN” for summer wear. This dress has WAY too many problems that need to be “fixed” by purchaser. Otherwise, I LOVE the longer length & comfort of this dress. Also, the armholes are neither too large nor revealing- just right. The dress allows one to wear a short t-shirt underneath (along with a modesty slip) to change to “look” of the dress. It looks best with a crisp white t-shirt (cropped, for hot days) or a white t -shirt with an interesting pattern). The dress arrived wrinkled and retains tons of wrinkles, yet is still OK for everyday wear in uncomfortably hot weather. I do not own an iron, but most people would need to iron this dress before wearing. I usually love E.F. clothing, but this dress fabric’s transparency was unexpected & quite embarrassing. Very disappointed in E.F.-still love Garnet Hill! ❤️

Rated 3 out of 5 by Susan9867432 from Shapeless I will be returning this dress. I ordered a small and it was huge and baggy, shapeless. Not worth the price.

Rated 2 out of 5 by MMacG from Not flattering Beautiful fabric, but the shape doesn’t work for me. It’s cut very wide and I was swimming in both the medium and the small.

Rated 1 out of 5 by Nuns from Quality I really like the style and I really like Eileen Fisher. But this dress the fabric was too thick. Because the fabric was not right and the cut was off. It look like big garbage bag.