Rated 4 out of 5 by loveSpain from quality sweater but.... I am a true size 12 in most name brands, 5'5" tall. I ordered up from large to Xlarge as i wanted a bit more oversized sweater for layering. I'm glad that I did, although a large would have been fine, just a bit more snug in the arms. The colors and aesthetic are accurately represented in photos. The Chai is lovely, a unique addition if you loves earthy neutrals. FIVE stars for sweater color, sizing and design; 3 stars for shipping prices outside the boundaries of industry standards.

Rated 3 out of 5 by tinamarie57 from Good cashmere. Poorly made My sweater arrived with a hole under the arm. Not something I’d expect at this price! I repaired the hole myself because the cost of returning it is ridiculous! Otherwise, nice sweater.

Rated 3 out of 5 by Bettina2 from Pretty but too roomy and long This sweater may look good on some but it was just way too much sweater for me and I even ordered it in an XS. It's very long and the pockets billow forward a bit which is not a flattering look. Sending it back.

Rated 3 out of 5 by HM4267 from Olive Cashmere Pocket Cardigan This is my first time shopping with GH. The cashmere quality is good. The reason that I gave it a 3 star is because the olive color is different from the picture. It has less green but more yellow in it. The negative part is the shipping cost (if you want to return the merchandise, you have to pay more shipping fees).

Rated 3 out of 5 by Beauannie from Shipping charge! I’ve shopped with Garnet Hill for over a decade. I love their cashmere. I’d like to try two sizes. To order them and return one will cost me 27.00! I love the sweater but I’ll have to find a cashmere cardigan else wear.

Rated 2 out of 5 by SF12345 from Runs very large Sadly, this didn’t work on any level for me. The sweater was huge and shapeless, and the oat color looked dingy on me. Definitely size down.

Rated 2 out of 5 by Sangeeta from Cashmere Pocket Cardigan I've had this cardigan for a few weeks. It is soft and feels great to wear. However, even though I have worn it only intermittently, it has pilled so much that it already looks old. I've had cashmere sweaters before and none of them have looked like this even after years and years of wear. I was excited to find this sweater and now I am disappointed in the quality, especially for the price. I would not buy it again.

Rated 2 out of 5 by Pcat1968 from Great but too large i bought the olive on sale in extra small. It was too long and too wide around. I am petite but an extra small should be for small people. It is frustrating that you do not have a fit for me. Had to return.

Rated 1 out of 5 by Jan272 from Great style, not good cashmere This sweater is not wearing well, although pretty at first. It didn't look super nice (more like an acrylic material) when I first got it an I buy a lot of cashmere. After wearing it once, it started pilling. I can't reccomend.

Rated 1 out of 5 by PacNW Vancouver from Sizing way off Horrible. It makes me look bloated. It has no tailoring.