Rated 5 out of 5 by Maltese Mama from Perfect.... Everything about this is Perfect! I love the length, weight, colors, (I got the Alpine Neutral colored one), and the texture! This is slightly larger than most other garments I take in an XL, but not ridiculously over sized. I am putting the other color on my list for my next Garnet Hill purchase!

Rated 4 out of 5 by Texas love from Super soft, good medium weight, great color This cardigan is a great weight, not too heavy, not too light, and really soft. Not itchy at all, and can be perfect with jeans, or classic and cool with a little black dress. I ordered my usual medium but it is drooping off my shoulders and the body is very wide. I’m now ordering the small and hoping it will be perfect. I’m keeping the med until I can compare them and send one back. Luckily it was still on sale. If you’re possibly between sizes, consider sizing down. Either way, it’s a gorgeous, classic sweater! The sizing was the only reason for only four stars.

Rated 3 out of 5 by Cloths Lover from Love the Cardigan but... runs quite large, on their website right now to order a small, normal size large, ordered a medium but still too big, alas going back due to not being able to get correct size.

Rated 3 out of 5 by TishInAustin from Nice sweater-odd cut I so wanted to love this sweater. I love Garnet Hill cashmere and the block pattern is beautiful on the model but the cut of the sweater is a bit odd. The arm holes are huge and hang down about 4" under my arm pits. The sleeves are baggy but not bell sleeves, I think that's why the model has them pushed up. I ordered a medium - I am 5' 9" and wear size 8 pants and size 10 blazers because I have broad shoulders but this sweater looked like my grandmothers fit. The color and cashmere are very nice. I think it's great if you want a really baggy style

Rated 2 out of 5 by SmilesBevie from There is a reason the back is not shown! Block YES, notched back collar...NO! Bad design for feature cardigan! Seam work is poor, esp neckline. You have a block design which is trendy and beautiful but then you ruined the look with an angular back neckline! Keep inline with block design and have a parallel color seam. Not sure if I'm keeping it and I was so excited for this one since it had spice color. I buy the feature cardigan every year, but this year's was a fail. Redesign with continuous standard round neckline collar with seamless stitching and parallel block colors posteriorly then it would be a 10/10. I've found that angle/notched seamwork necklines wear prematurely so it's a failed design