Rated 5 out of 5 by Wild Yam from Cozy, beautiful! The feel of this dress is just so soft and warm. Very nice quality. A little shorter than I'd like, (I'm 5'4") but with nice tall boots it will be fine.

Rated 4 out of 5 by DiscoDancerBoston from Great except the fit...pains me to return It really pains me to have to return this dress. I purchased the Midnight Indigo, which is a GORGEOUS purple color. It's slightly heathered, which you can't really tell from the photos, but that adds to the interest. The cashmere is thick, tightly knit, and obviously of excellent quality. That said, the fit is so completely awful on me that I'm not even sure I could take it to a talented tailor to fix it. I'm 5'6", 140-ish lbs, and I have an athletic/straight body with long limbs. I work out every day, so despite having had two kids I have a fairly flat tummy. Most off-the-rack clothing fits me quite well. That said, this dress clings in all the wrong places and is baggy in places where it should be more form-fitting. I ordered a small, which lately has been my size in GH (generally a size 6-8 in most brands). It's definitely the right size--shoulders, sleeve length, overall length, are all good. But the back (above the waist) is oddly baggy, yet it clings to my seat--which normally I wouldn't mind, except it also "creates" a tummy on me. If you look at the model wearing the green dress, you will see the same effect on her--and she is taller and slimmer than I am, for sure. I'm just not sure what the thought process was in the shaping of this dress. It looks fine from the front, by the way. But I just can't handle how bad it is from the side. It looks like a cocoon. Really wanted to love this one :(

Rated 4 out of 5 by BK44 from Beautiful but roomy I have the exact same issue as another reviewer: I am between sizes and probably could wear an XS, but I bought a S as I didn't want it to be tight. It looks just a bit too roomy, although it feels like wearing a hug. Indigo is a lovely purple with a bluish tinge. Length is great for me--I'm 5'5" and it comes to the middle of my kneecap. Sleeves are an inch too long. Took a star off for the fit issue (wish there was more consistency with sizing) and the price (holy cow).

Rated 4 out of 5 by Zoom Zoom from Cashmere Button-Sleeve Sweater Dress I purchased the midnight indigo color which is purple. The dress is warm, the material is thick and it is cozy. I usually wear XS or Small in Garnet Hill. I am curvy but small. And I am 5’4. It has been a challenge for me this year in regards to dresses, seems every dress has so much material around the waist and back area. Same case with this dress. I ordered size Small (4-6). Maybe I needed size XS?? But I didn’t want it tight, I wanted it to skim over my body. The dress also has long sleeves, which is what I wanted but they seem 2 inches too long. I have long arms and this is the first time any dress sleeve has been too long. I want to love this dress. I don’t want the hassle to send it back so I plan on keeping it. Please, Garnet Hill go back to the days when dresses were tailored perfectly to flatter bodies. Not everyone is apple shaped. I will post pic later.

Rated 1 out of 5 by Sj37 from Way too large! I loved the color of this dress but the XS was huge on me even though that’s the size I normally wear. It fit like a loose bag and hung below my knees—not at all flattering!