Rated 4 out of 5 by Tcandia from Fab all-around puffer Good fit, color, price. Not the best coat if you need super warm( -20F ) but a great choice for wearing layers, walking around town, beach, and with the bottom up zipper, perfect for a winter car coat. Size runs large - order down a size and enjoy!!

Rated 4 out of 5 by Mommy3boys from Love the color I have three black down coats of varying lengths. The blue is a nice change. I am 5'6" and around 125 lbs. & the small is roomy - could easily wear multiple layers underneath. I got it on sale & am pleased with it. I don't love the stitching on the back which is why I took away a star. Maybe if I had ordered an XS the stitching would have played a role in the look of the coat. It's pretty shapeless, which is okay with me. Haven't worn in super cold weather so can't reflect upon it's warmth. It seems well made.

Rated 3 out of 5 by LoreenK from Teal color is lovely Love the color, not the fit. Runs very large. I normally wear a size 4, ordered the small and am swimming in this coat!

Rated 3 out of 5 by LMT1 from Not as warm as I had hoped The coat is comfortable and flattering, but not as warm as I had hoped it would be. I hate the cold. I wore the coat outside for a few minutes over a short sleeved shirt in 45 degree weather and was chilly. Fortunately, it is roomy enough to wear bulky layers underneath.

Rated 3 out of 5 by IceDancer999 from Disappointed I did not find the exposed zippdrcagtractive. But what made me return the coat was that it would not be warm; there were no knit wristlets inside the sleeves, the neck had no closure (attractive neckline but too open). It was not particularly stylish, either. Too big.

Rated 2 out of 5 by Amryillis from Looks nice I live in northern MN and this cost is NOT warm. It was 27 degrees out and I wore this coat and after about half an hour outside I was chilled to the bone. It is true to size and looks good on but don’t buy it for warmth. Really disappointing.

Rated 2 out of 5 by boris from Alpine Puffer Coat Beautifully designed coat and beautiful color, but the size is much larger than actual size. I fit in 0-2 or XS of Garnet Hill items, but this coat (size-XS) was like size-Medium to my body size. Sadly I had to return. If the size fit you, this coat is beautiful and warm!

Rated 2 out of 5 by Native plant lady from Wasn’t up to my expectations The coat looks very nice on the model, but when I got it I was disappointed at how unflattering it looked on me. The large zipper that is asymmetric looks weird I think. It felt very light, and I wondered how warm it would be in the dead of winter.

Rated 2 out of 5 by KK California from Odd fit I did not like this jacket at all, I retuned it. Runs very large. Quality seemed ok, but I'm not sure how warm it really would be.

Rated 1 out of 5 by kliss from Buyer beware I wanted so badly to love this coat and decided to go for it, having read many reviews pointing out issues with the coat but other reviews from people who loved it. Sadly, I am among those who found this coat very disappointing. At 5'6 and 120lbs, I tried a small and an extra small and I was swimming in both. Now, I know this coat is a puffer and not meant to be form fitting or necessarily flattering, but with the virtually shapeless style and a very large and pretty unattractive asymmetrical zipper (which I thought would be a nice and unique touch but ended up looking tacky) I looked awful. Also, please be aware that this coat IS NOT warm. There was almost zero down filling the coat, it honestly looked and felt more like two pieces of nylon with nothing between them. Do you see the nicely puffed images on the website photos? Well, that is not how the coat actually looks. Be prepared to wear an empty sleeping bag that will hang from your body and provide no warmth or protection from the elements. Sadly, both coats are going back no matter how great a price I got. Totally useless. Please make a stylish and warm winter coat next year, Garnett Hill.

Rated 1 out of 5 by Puffy winter from Not good quality Poor fit arms too long waist too big shoulders wrong cutm

Rated 1 out of 5 by winter wit from Nope Garnet Hill missed the mark on this one. The fabric and fill were flimsy. The fit was weird. The elastic in the back gave the bottom half a bell shape. I’m 5’4”, and the sleeves were way too long, definitely not for petites. The price did not reflect the value at all.

Rated 1 out of 5 by Anonymous from Defective This coat was such a disappointment. Style and fit great but 2/3 empty of down. The bottom half of the coat was simply an empty shell. More down in the hood than in the entire coat.